Since I began my Emily Henry journey with Beach Read, I thought it best to begin “Dismantling the Trope Tuesdays” there as well.
Once a month, I'll be dissecting the unique way Emily Henry uses familiar romance tropes in her novels to revive the romance genre.
![]() |
| Photo by Thought Catalog on Unsplash |
If you’ve read my first post, you know I talked about Emily Henry’s novels helping me abandon my aversion to the romance genre.
I picked up Beach Read out of twisted curiosity, expecting to be proven right about my skepticism.
But, I put down the book thinking about the complexities of both romance and life in general.
What struck me most about it though, was that Henry managed to use familiar tropes in storytelling to present a love story with depth.
I began to think about why I despised the regular romance novel in the first place.
What was it about them that had me superciliously scoffing at them in passing? What caused me to be so blind with rage at a harmless story about love?
I supposed it had something to do with the predictability of it all.
The girl falling for the boy next door. The unrealistic opposites attract situation. The two characters who loathe each other slowly realizing that they actually love each other.
I even thought that maybe the hatred stemmed from my own lack of experiencing the true love these books marketed. I thought that maybe I was on the outside of some exclusive love club.
Because I didn’t get it, I thought maybe I couldn’t enjoy it.
But, now I see my problem wasn’t with the romance. I was just so focused on the romance that I couldn’t see what other perspectives the story could offer me.
I don’t mean that every romance novel needs this exploration of the true human experience. What speaks to me as a reader, might not speak to another. Sometimes, the tropes are enough.
She Reads Romance Books is a great place to find romance novels that might speak to you.
But for me, Emily Henry put an entirely new spin on the genre. I don’t feel that the same predictability is there and that made me understand that the romance genre isn’t exclusive.
Just a heads up: this post discusses some plot points that you might not want to spoil for yourself, so if you haven’t yet read this book you might consider coming back to this post after you have!
Breaking It Down
If you don’t know what a trope is, I’d classify it as a pattern an author uses in a story. A trope could be a situation, a character type, the dynamic between characters, or a theme.
The bottom line is that readers can automatically recognize it because they’ve seen it before.
In Beach Read, Henry presents to us these tropes:
- Enemies-to-lovers
- Grumpy versus sunshine
- Forced proximity
Enemies-to-lovers is pretty self-explanatory.
We see two characters who consider themselves to be enemies for whatever reason.
As the story progresses, we see their relationship shift from animosity to affection because they realize they had the wrong idea about each other.
Grumpy versus sunshine is often depicted with one character being pessimistic or jaded and the other being a ball of sunshine, optimistic and playful.
These differences in personality create attraction because the characters seek some kind of balance.
Forced proximity illustrates a story of two people having no choice but to be close to one another. With this proximity comes a lack of emotional separation, leading to attraction.
In Beach Read, January Andrews and Augustus Everett fit these prototypes.
As college rivals, January and Augustus are both authors writing in completely different genres. January for romance, Augustus for literary fiction.
When January's father passes away, she moves into his beach house to try to get rid of her writer’s block, only to find out her neighbor is Augustus.
And then the plot thickens, because they devise a plan to attempt writing a book in each other’s genres, forcing them out of their comfort zones and into reconsideration about what stories the world needs.
Recognize the pattern?
It sounds like the perfect romantic setup. But, Henry takes it beyond the romance.
Why Is This Trope Overdone?
To be completely frank, the setup is nothing new. That’s not to say that this familiarity is the worst thing in the world.
People find familiarity comforting and satisfying and so why shouldn’t they indulge in those types of stories?
But if you think that relying on the trope is what hurts the book, then this is the place for you.
You know that eventually, the enemies are going to cease their bickering to give in to each other. The sunshine’s smile will break down the grump’s steel walls.
The forced proximity will be the not so invisible string that brings the characters together.
The trope can make it all feel so…one-dimensional. As flat as the piece of paper the writing is on.
I wanted to feel the characters' emotions as if they were my own. I wanted to know what their deepest secrets were. I wanted to know who they were beyond love.
Because isn’t that how real life works?
We carry our insecurities, our history, our worldview with us into the relationships we develop. A story doesn’t feel as authentic without the details of real life we’re often trying to escape.
That’s where I think Emily Henry works her magic.
![]() |
| Photo by Haley Parson on Unsplash |
The Emily Henry Approach
Emily Henry uses the tropes as her guiding light. They're not the sole plot. The personal struggle of the characters is the crux of the story.
We can start with the enemies-to-lovers.
January and Augustus aren’t rivals because the story needs tension to be appealing. Their disagreement comes from their differing definitions about fiction and life.
In their college creative writing class, they diverge on the point of what role stories have in the world and how writers approach that.
These differences mirror their choices in which genres they write for, giving them grounds to brutally criticise each other.
But these characters don’t completely understand each other. Their experiences and assumptions lead them to judgement and as the story progresses, we see how they grapple with their misunderstandings.
This then sets the stage for their relationship to be more than just two people realizing they’re attracted to one another after being rivals for so long.
Their relationship becomes a glittering opportunity to reconsider the assumptions they’ve made about one another.
That process also leads to these characters looking inward and clearly seeing how they must make reconsiderations about their own lives.
For example, January, despite being a romance author, develops a skewed sense of love.
She built her entire career around writing the perfect happy endings, but when she finds out that her father had maintained a secret life while having an affair, her understanding of love shifts.
The house she moved into becomes its own kind of character, a culmination of the secrets kept by her father who was someone she deeply trusted and looked up to as a figure of undying love.
This betrayal January feels is paired with the navigation of the grief that comes with her father’s death.
She is faced with the question of how she can write these happy endings she’s so familiar with if they were never that familiar after all.
The writer’s block she experiences is tied to her overall struggle to make sense of deep grief, betrayal, and the realization that the people we love can sometimes hurt us the most.
I think that Emily Henry uses January to demonstrate that romance isn’t a magical cure for the complexities of life. Falling in love with her rival doesn’t erase the damage her father’s lies have done.
To reform her opinion of love, she must overcome the hurt.
Honestly, I find that more relatable than the whole enemies-to-lovers thing.
Now, I’d like to tackle the grumpy versus sunshine and forced proximity tropes.
At first blush, January and Augustus fit this exact trope.
January is the romance writer who views the world in a positive light, sunshine and rainbows if you will. Augustus is the literary fiction writer who is serious and sees the world in facts.
But in simply attaching these labels to these characters, we overlook their histories and experiences.
January was raised believing her parents had a happy marriage, only to find out that wasn’t the case at all. And Augustus grew up experiencing child abuse and the messy divorce of his parents.
Their outlooks and writing styles are tied to their life experiences, their fears, their core values.
By writing in each other’s genres, they agree to set aside their assumptions and understandings of the world around them. They have to step out of their comfort zones and question how they see the world and themselves.
Doesn’t that give you chills?
Another aspect of this situation is that the challenge, as well as living next door to each other, forces them to spend more time together. This is where forced proximity comes into play.
Here, we see that their circumstances facilitate their closeness, but what really matters is what they discover in this proximity.
So What Do You Mean By Dismantling?
Now you know a little more about Emily Henry and the way she dismantles the tropes…right? I mean is that what she really does?
I think a better way to put it would be how Emily Henry reframes the tropes. She dismantles the idea that these tropes make romance novels predictable and unworthy of a reader’s time.
In Beach Read the tropes enemies-to-lovers, grumpy versus sunshine, and forced proximity don’t just push two characters to fall in love, they challenge the core of what these characters believe about life.
In doing so, the tropes also challenge readers to set aside their assumptions.
This is what I find so intriguing about Emily Henry’s novels. She turns a love story into something more.
Now, I don’t scoff at the romance section because I know it can be for everybody. If you're in the mood for a book that'll serve as distraction from the chaos of life but still has substance, give Beach Read a shot.
And stay tuned for more details about Henry's next novel called Modern Classic, coming out on April 6, 2027.
Happy reading! If you made it this far, let me know in the comments: Are you already an EmHen fan or will you be adding her books to your TBR?



